The Vintage Villain — A Chocolate Ale Sllyabub Cake Recipe with Homemade Ale Ice Cream

vintage villain Chocolate Ale Cake recipe BakeThisCake

The Vintage Villain Cake is a dark chocolate ale cake made with a secret potion that just might knock the red and white striped witches long socks right off your feet! Slather your creation with chocolate ganache and top each slice with our homemade ale ice cream and you’ve got a classic vintage party on your hands!

vintage chocolate ale cake by bake this cake

Secret Potion Alert! We’re gonna ratchet up the awesome factor by brewing up a secret potion to swirl into our dark beauty! This luxe brew is the money factor that creates one of those dreamy party cakes with big flavor.

Secret potion for Vintage Villain Cake Bake This Cake

What’s a syllabub for glory sakes? Some food historians claim the syllabub (“sill-a-bub”) only for drinks of ale mixed with milk or cider. There’s a famous syllabub drink recipe from the amazing Mary Randolph. Her maiden name was the same as her married name because, well, she married her cousin. She was related to Pocahontas and her brother was the guv’nor of Virginia and son-in-law to President Jefferson. In her wildly popular cookbook that took 17 years to craft, “The Virginia Housewife“, (copyrighted 1828, published by John Plaskitt, Baltimore, in 1836) Mrs. Randolph spells it out thusly:

Mary Randolph's Syllabub Recipe w frame bake this cake

But this fun syllabub word works on a much larger scale than just drinks (or even food). It’s really about the interesting juxtaposition of combinations, like acidity mixed with dairy (oh, just think: demon and angel, go for it!). And it works here because this old-fashioned cake is about: beer and buttermilk. You know–the dark sees the light, or, rather, the light sees the dark, that sort of thing. We should call it “the syllabub effect”.

Vintage Villain Cake poster bakethiscake

The Adored Villain:  Admit it, you must! Everyone loves a mysterious dark horse villain, am I right? A dangerous ruffian mixed with nuances of humor and intelligence, the mannered gentleman gambler with a streed-cred background or the lovable monster — the pure and sweet mixed with lurking shadows of danger.

Boris Karloff as Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein

First American edition, 1899, Bram Stoker’s Dracula, Doubleday & McClure, NY.

Top 5 Literature Villains: Just to get us in the mood, here’s the top 5 villains in literature, according to The Christian Science Monitor. The envelope please!

1. Erin the Moor from Shakespeare’s “Titus Andronicus
2. Sauron from Tolkien’s “The Lord of the Rings
3. Pa Finn from Twain’s “The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn
4. Wicked Witch of the West from Baum’s “The Wonderful Wizard of Oz
5. Count Dracula from Stoker’s “Dracula

Top 20 Vintage Villain Films: And the award for the best 20 vintage villain films for a cool Vintage Villain Movie Night Party to accompany your dark and dangerous Vintage Villain Cake? Before Halloween sneaks up, you must click > here < to gather up some cool classics from our favorites list.

Top 20 Coolest Vintage Halloween Films BakeThisCake

Vintage Cake Research! I love the 1933 edition of “The Congressional Cook Book” by members of The Congressional Club. It has a Foreward by Eleanor Roosevelt and the best-moist-chocolate-cake recipe by Mrs. E. T. Sanford, (widow of the Supreme Court Justice), “Three Layer Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Filling”. But we just “hadta” bump it up a tad, in that syllabub kind of way, until we morphed this baby into a dark Dubliner style chocolate cake that rocks!

Congressional Cook Book Bake This Cake

And it starts with a (yes!) secret potion! I’m going to walk you through a simple Irish concoction. And you don’t have to be a witch or a warlock, or even have a cauldron over licking flames, to make this potion. You just need a little slow food time in your pocket for a slow simmer flavor reduction. Make the potion the night before, if you can, to create a lustrous homemade small batch that brings the cake to life with a strange and wonderful flavor kick. And we have a substitution idea for the teetotalers too.

beer cake potion bake this cake

Okay! Let’s bake this cake!

Vintage Villain Cake: Chocolate Ale Syllabub Cake Recipe:

1. Secret Potion Preamble: First, we’ll make our secret potion!

If you’re making this cake for children (or you’d rather lose the alcohol), try substituting a strong brew of caffeine-free tea for the ale.
Tip: If you’re also making Homemade Ale Ice Cream (recipe below) to serve with your cake, make a double batch of the potion.

Wild Range Amber Ale beer for Chocolate Ale Cake Recipe BakeThis Cake

In a heavy large saucepot, bring to a boil, then immediately reduce to a very low simmer for about 1-1/2 hours or until you achieve a thickened dark syrup of about 1/8 cup (just 2 Tablespoons):
1 bottle amber or dark ale beer* (12 fluid ounces, 1-1/2 cups) (We used Wild Amber Ale) (*Non-alcohol substitute: 1-1/2 cups strong caffeine-free herbal tea)

Tip: The beer bubbles up prior to reduction so be sure to have a large pot to prevent overflow. Reduction times can vary so watch over your little cauldron.

beer reduction for chocolate ale cake bake this cake

In a cup, stir:
the prepared reduced 2 Tablespoons of reduction beer syrup
1 Tablespoon dark molasses
1 Tablespoon strong coffee
1 Tablespoon real vanilla extract, fine quality
Tip: The whole secret potion will be less than 1/4 cup.

Secret Potion for Vintage Villain Syllabub Chocolate Ale Cake Bake This Cake

2. Prepare your cake pans: Butter and flour two 9″ x 2″ round cake pans, or spray them with vegetable spray, line them with parchment paper and spray them again.

3. Now onto the vintage cake prep:

Using an electric mixer, beat on high-speed for about 2 minutes::
1 cup (2 cubes) unsalted butter, room temperature
2 cups sugar

Tip: Because we’re using a lot of butter, and because we’re going Irish style, we used a fine quality grass-fed butter from Kerrygold.

Creaming butter with sugar for chocolate ale cake recipe Bake this cake

Beat into the butter-sugar mixture on high-speed for 2 to 5 minutes until light and fluffy:
4 large fork-stirred eggs

Tip: Soak your eggs for a few minutes in warm water to bring them to room temperature – for a nicer lift.

Adding beaten eggs to chocolate ale cake recipe Bake this Cake

In a medium bowl, mix with a fork:
1-1/3 cups warmed buttermilk (substitute: 1 cup warm water with 4 Tablespoons of dried cultured buttermilk)
1 cup cocoa powder (I used Ghirardelli natural unsweetened cocoa)
the prepared beer reduction sauce (the secret potion)

Mixing secret beer potion into cocoa for villain cake recipe bake this cake

To the creamed butter-sugar-egg mixture, beat in alternating one-third portions until just blended:
2 cups cake flour
the prepared mixture of buttermilk/cocoa/secret potion

chocolate ale syllabub cake recipe bake this cake

In a cup, mix with a fork:
2 teaspoons cider vinegar
2 teaspoons baking soda

Tip: This is another (essential) secret potion!

 baking soda potion for chocolate cake bake this cake

Beat into the batter the bubbling baking soda mixture and then increase the blender to high-speed for about 3 minutes until the batter is lightened in color and becomes light and fluffy.

Tip: It is unusual to beat the final batter for this length of time, but this is necessary to achieve a light and airy batter.

Beating the chocolate ale batter recipe bake this cake

Divide and pour the batter into the prepared cake pans.

vintage chocolate ale cake batter recipe by bake this cake

4.) Let’s bake this puppy!

Bake on the center oven rack at 350 for 30-35 mins (to an internal temperature of about 200 degrees) until a toothpick test shows clean.

Baked chocolate ale cakes bake this cake

Remove to wire racks to cool thoroughly.

Chocolate Ganache Cake Filling:

Chop 3.5 ounces (about 3/4 cup chopped) fine quality dark chocolate. (I used Green & Black’s 70% Organic Dark Chocolate)

Heat 1 cup heavy cream on the stovetop or in the microwave to just simmering (or just hot) and pour the hot cream into the bowl of chopped chocolate with a dash of pure vanilla extract and stir to cool until thickened to spreading consistency. Sprinkle a touch of powdered sugar to achieve a bit of sweetness.

dark ganache recipe bake this cake

Spread that glorious chocolate cream on the bottom layer of the cake, then just sprinkle the top with a light dusting of powdered sugar.

Filling the chocolate ale cake with ganache bakethiscake

You may want to top the cake with a lightly whipped heavy cream sweetened lightly with a little powdered sugar. You might also want to shave a little chocolate over the top of the cream for extra pizzaz.

Chocolate Ale Syllabub BakeThisCake

Homemade Chocolate Ale Ice Cream: Light and creamy chocolate ice cream with an intruiguing hint of amber ale.

Follow the recipe for the secret ale potion above. While the ale potion is still warm, stir in to dissolve:
1/4 cup sugar

Cool it in the fridge or chuck it in the freezer for 10 minutes for a fast chill.

In large bowl, whisk thoroughly:
2 cups heavy whipping cream
1 cup milk (2% is fine)
1/4 cup blue agave syrup (substitute: light corn syrup)
1/4 cup light corn syrup
the prepared and chilled secret potion syrup

Chill and churn according to the ice cream machine manufacturer’s instructions. (I churned in my machine for 20 minutes)

Optional: At the last churn, mix in 1/3 cup very finely chopped dark chocolate bits.

Pack it and freeze it for 4 hours prior to serving.

Tip: If you don’t have an ice cream machine, just freeze the ice cream mixture for half hour intervals, whipping or stirring, returning to freezer, repeating until the mixture hardens.

Chocolate Ale Ice Cream Recipe Bake This Cake

Thank you for joining me on this little vintage cake baking journey. I SO appreciate your enthusiasm for historic recipes and I just love to hear your comments as you experiment with them.

Don’t forget to send me pics of your Vintage Villain Party!

Slice of Chocolate Ale Villain Cake with Ale Ice Cream BakeThisCake

I hope you can follow us on Instagram and Facebook. We also have a fun Halloween Board on Pinterest that I think you might enjoy.

Happy vintage baking!


Leslie Macchiarella photo by Julie Macchiarella

You may also enjoy reading:

Mary Todd Lincoln’s Vanilla Almond Cake

Fresh Banana Frosting for Betty’s Banana Layer Cake

Miss Leslie’s Boston Sherry Butter Cake

Homemade Pumpkin Bread

Irish Halloween collage bakethiscake

9 thoughts on “The Vintage Villain — A Chocolate Ale Sllyabub Cake Recipe with Homemade Ale Ice Cream

Please leave a comment (some delay in posting)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s