Fudge Sponge Drop Cookies for the Holiday Cookie Exchange Party

Vintage Lemon Sponge Drop Cookies with Double Fudge Filling BakethisCake

We’re baking old-fashioned sponge drops made from a simple vintage sponge cake recipe. Then we’re filling them, sandwich style, with decadent double fudge ’cause it’s time for the Holiday Cookie and Cook Book Exchange Party with Food Bloggers Los Angeles!

Stacked vintage sponge drops filled with fudge bake this cake

Yes, it’s a holiday crowd, so that would be 200 crisp little cookies filling up the kitchen with a heavenly aroma — and filling up every cookie sheet, cooling rack and tray that can be found or borrowed.

Sponge Cake Cookies cooling on trays and racks Bake This Cake

Here is what I learned during this cookie baking adventure:

1. My lower oven bakes 2 minutes slower than my top oven.
2. Pie pans do not make very good cookie pans, even in a pinch.
3. Having 2 kitchen timers comes in handy once in a while.
4. You can slide at least 2 cookies on the spatula at one time.
5. The batter will taste exactly like the cookies — so taste it to adjust flavoring before you bake it (a tiny bit won’t kill you, I don’t think).
6. Loud music and baking go hand in hand.
7. Fudge gets thick and hard pretty fast if you don’t keep it warm and stirred.
8. There’s no time for extra chores when cookies are in the oven because it’s on to the next batch immediately.
9. If you make a mistake, there’s a likely way to keep moving forward.
10. After a major baking spree, cleaning the kitchen before going to bed will keep you sane in the morning.

Holiday Cookie Exhange Party Cookies with FBLA bakethiscake

Testing Old-fashioned Recipes:

FBLA Cookie Exchange Table Food Bloggers Los Angeles FBLA bakethiscakeI pre-tested this simple little recipe to perfection. Actually, I tested LOTS of cookies all month prior to this event. Cakes are usually my realm so I was fretting, I admit. I mean, food writers will bring it when it comes to sharing their foodie treats so I wanted to make something special just like my buds. The recipe I decided to use was published in 1881. It’s a very simple old-fashioned cake recipe from “The Complete Bread, Cake and Cracker Baker…” by J. Thompson Gill. Just 3 ingredients: flour, powdered sugar and a whole bunch of eggs. For the cookie, Mr. Gill simply suggested adding lemon flavor to the cake batter and dropping little walnut-sized bits on pans to transform cake into cookies. Voila! Sounds charming to me. Course, on the big night for baking I goofed by separating a dozen instead of 9 eggs.

Double Fudge Sponge Drop Cookies recipe from BakeThisCake

Luckily, I have a gazillion old cook books so I looked up other mid-1800’s sponge cake recipes and found that I could easily morph my blunder into a perfect 1884 sponge cake by using C. W. Schlumpf’s recipe from “A Practical Guide for the Cake and Bread Baker”. That’s because the latter recipe is the same except that it uses a dozen eggs. Perfect! And that is how we roll on a Friday night. Go with the flow and turn up the music louder.

Bessie photo bombs the cookie shot bakethiscake

Bessie photo bombs the cookie shoot

Since I’ve now made both versions, I can’t tell which one was best (but if you’re running low on eggs, it turns out you can short a few and still come out strong). Plus the second one is easier to remember: 1 pound of flour, 1 pound of powdered sugar and a dozen eggs (plus flavoring).  I’ve computed the measurements for you in measuring cups and I’ll show you step-by-step with photos how to make them. There are many ways to make a sponge cake. Mr. G says to beat the eggs and sugar as a starter but I thought I’d stick with whipping the egg whites and folding them in. Frankly, I don’t think it makes much difference, I tried both ways –so if you’re short on time just beat the eggs and sugar, add the flour and flavoring and you’re good to go.

Sponge Drop Cookie Recipe Instructions:

1. Grate 1 or 2 fresh lemons to achieve:
3 Tablespoons of fresh lemon juice
1 Tablespoon of fresh lemon zest
Tip: Substitute your favorite flavor with orange, vanilla, almond, etc.

Grated lemon peel for old fashioned sponge drop cookies recipe bakethiscake

2. Sift before measuring out:
1 pound (3-3/4 cups) of powdered sugar
Tip: Instead of “real” sifting, I stirred the powdered sugar in a mesh strainer over a bowl — for that light-as-air mounding effect. 🙂

Sifting powdered sugar for sponge cake cookies  bakethiscake

3. Sift before measuring out:
1 pound (3-2/3 cups)  all-purpose flour

Sifted flour for sponge cake cookies recipe bake this cake

4. Separate into whites and yolks:
12 large eggs
Tip: For this many eggs, I drop each egg white into a little cup before transferring to the egg whites bowl to ensure no bits of broken yolk damage the lovely whites.

Separating a dozen eggs for vintage lemon sponge cake recipe bake this cake

5. Beat the egg whites until foamy (about 1 minute on high-speed), add the fresh lemon juice to fully incorporate, beat in the sifted powdered sugar in stages on low-speed then increasing to high-speed (about 1 to 3 minutes) until it all becomes perfectly light and fluffy and glossy.

egg whites lemon juice and powdered sugar bake this cake

6. Change to a larger bowl if needed (I did) and gently fold in the flour and the lemon zest with a spatula.
Tip: Take a little taste and see if there is enough lemon flavor for you.

Folding flour and lemon zest into sponge batter bake this cake

7. Stir the egg yolks with a fork until smooth then use a spatula to gently fold the yolks into the batter until all is well incorporated.

Folding yolks into sponge cake batter bake this cake

8. Scoop the batter into a piping bag fitted with a No. 6 Wilton tip (or just cut a small hole in the corner of a large plastic baggie) and pipe little 2″ circles on a cookie tray sprayed with cooking spray. Or just drop the batter onto the pan using a teaspoon – and then you would be making a true “drop” cookie. 🙂
Tip: You will have to match up the cookie sizes for the fudge sandwiches so try to keep them uniform and round.

Piping sponge cake batter for drop cookies bake this cake

9. Bake at 325 degrees for 8 to 10 minutes until the edges of the cookies turn golden brown and the tops of the cookies lose most of their sheen. Immediately remove the cookies to a rack to cool completely.
Tip: The bottom of the cookies should be just lightly golden brown.

old-fashioned Sponge Cookies baked to light golden bake this cake

10. Prepare the double fudge recipe (doubled and prepared in 2 separate batches, with a little left over).
Tip: Keep the pot of fudge on the stove as you work to fill the cookies so that you can warm it and stir if it gets too thick. It will smooth as it is re-warmed and stirred.

Here is a collage that summarizes the steps required for the fudge filling with the full recipe here. If you click on the link, it opens in a separate window.

Double Fudge Preparation for Sponge Drop Cookies Filling bake this cake

11. Frost a cookie bottom using about 1/2 teaspoon of warm fudge for each cookie, depending on the sizes you’ve made. Sandwich another cookie on top and gently press down on the cookie sandwich until the fudge reaches the outer edges of the cookies. Place the sandwiched cookie on the cooling rack until the fudge hardens in a few minutes.
Tip: Keep a damp rag nearby to keep your fingers fudge free and to prevent cookies smudges (course, a little fudge dribble never hurts).

Side close up of fudge filling sponge drop cookies bake this cake

Now go ahead and make up a whole bunch of these lovely little darlings!

Sponge Cake Cookies piled up high for Christmas bake this cake

You will have a little extra fudge from a double batch so just slide the warm fudge into a little bowl and throw some pecan halves on top. Just cool it and slice it into tiny squares (it’s quite rich).

Homemade Pecan Fudge using Double Fudge Frosting Recipe bake this cake

On to the Holiday Cookie Exchange Party with the amazing Food Bloggers Los Angeles. And EVERY single cookie that you see on this tray (plus MORE) are available for you to bake courtesy of FBLA by clicking >> HERE (opens in a new window). Also, see a link to the food writers’ cookie recipe posts below. Enjoy!

Red Vintage Tray filled with food bloggers holiday cookies bakethiscake

Oh, I also learned from this cookie baking adventure: Hanging with food writers means you will learn something new, you will talk to someone interesting and you will eat something incredible.

Have a great holiday season! I look forward to seeing you in the evenings and weekends on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. You might even want to check out our Holiday Pinterest Board.

Happy Vintage Baking!


Leslie Odell Macchiarella

You may also enjoy reading:

Betty’s Banana Layer Cake (bakethiscake.com)
Vintage Black Banana Bread (bakethisbread.com)
Vintage Devil’s Food Cake (bakethiscake.com)
Homemade Maraschino Cherries (bakethiscake.com)

FBLA food writers holiday party collage bakethiscake

FBLA 2013 Cookie Exchange Recipes:

Non-Cookie Items:

15 thoughts on “Fudge Sponge Drop Cookies for the Holiday Cookie Exchange Party

  1. Leslie- I really enjoyed these lovely little cookie- so did Joel- and loved the process photos on your post – it looked like Invasion of the Cookie Snatchers! I’m a night owl too so I understand… how late were you up baking these babies? Come clean… and speaking of clean, it really helps with my peace of mind to clean the kitchen before falling into bed – though the sky doesn’t fall if it’s not going to happen 🙂 Have a great Holiday- Judy

  2. Hi Leslie- it was fun hanging out with you at the FBLA cookie exchange. Your cake circles seemed so perfect, I thought you baked them in little molds. I like how you talk openly in this post about your process making cookies. We all have doubts and glitches in the kitchen, so it’s nice to know I’m not alone. Also, you said you were baking at night. Do you have any photography tips for photographing in the kitchen at night? Thanks, Dana

Please leave a comment (some delay in posting)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s